Best 4-Seater Convertibles of 2020

Drop-top enjoyment and the ability to transport more than just two occupants is a winning combination that makes 4-seater convertibles so irresistible. Unlike a 2-seater that functions better as a weekend toy for a single person or as a second car, convertibles with back seats offer the best of both worlds. As with any open-top vehicle, the kind of roof will be an important consideration, as is luggage capacity when the top is stowed. Of course, back seats can also double as additional storage space when unoccupied.

Finding The Best 4-Seater Convertible Cars

Buying any new or used vehicle for sale requires you to compare key factors like power outputs, value for money, safety features, and reliability records. Over and above this, shortlisting the best 4-seater convertibles requires a more specific evaluation of aspects like roof design and how roomy the back seats actually are. You’ll also want to know whether the Jaguar or Porsche you have your eye on drives as well as its hardtop equivalent. Here’s what to look out for:

  • Roof design: Do you really need a metal top or will a lighter fabric one do? Electric operation is convenient but is more expensive to maintain and also poses packaging complexities.
  • Dynamics: A loss of rigidity is often the consequence of choosing a cabriolet. An extended test drive could help you identify if the compromise is worthwhile.
  • Legroom: A rear seat doesn’t automatically mean you’ll get the spacious interior of a full-size sedan. Be sure to play the role of a rear passenger when conducting your test.
  • Trunk: Does the roof impinge on cargo space too much for you to enjoy your cabriolet in winter?
  • Price: Whether you’re buying a used example at under 20k or considering a six-figure luxury cabrio, you’ll likely be paying a premium over the hardtop derivative.

Commonalities of Convertible 4-Seaters

If all you wanted was a wind-in-your-hair sports car that entertains above all else, you’d get something like a two-seater Audi TT, Mazda MX-5, or a Jaguar F-Type. But a 4- or 5-seater is different - for starters, these cabriolets are generally lengthier to free up enough space for a second row. Unfortunately, this comes with the downside of added weight, so a more powerful engine is preferable in this application. With more weight to lug around than a hardtop, the economy could also dip.

What to Consider Before Buying

Not everyone has the luxury of being able to own two cars, where one fulfills a purpose that the other can’t. If a 2-door drop-top is to be your only mode of transport, it’s useful to know the positives and negatives of this type of vehicle, whether you’re using it for everyday commuting or weekend jaunts. If any of these points are a dealbreaker, you’re probably better off with a 4-5 seater sedan or even an SUV.

Pros

  • No need to choose between top-down motoring and passengers
  • More stylish than a 5-person sedan
  • More storage capacity behind the driver
  • As comfortable as a coupe with the top up

Cons

  • More expensive than a regular hardtop
  • Electric roof mechanisms are pricey to repair
  • Many cabrios have poor rear legroom
  • Construction generally leads to heavier weight

Top Four-seater Convertibles

What kind of makes and models could you expect to find in this segment? Well, the four-seater convertible body style tends to be dominated by luxury brands. Examples include the Mercedes S-Class, the Bentley Continental GT, and the BMW M8, although the latter isn’t the most spacious. There are a couple of more affordable alternatives, however, such as topless iterations of the Ford Mustang and Mini Cooper.

For more information about each model, you can refer to our reviews, including those for older 2018 and 2019 years. Here, we list each trim, along with pricing, ride/handling impressions, and comments on the interior layout. If you can’t decide between a four-seater cabrio or five-seater coupe, our assessments will get you closer to making an informed decision.

FAQs

What is the best open-air car for four?

The top-rated vehicle of this body style that we’ve tested is the 2020 Mercedes-Benz S-Class, which holds a BuzzScore of 9.5 out of 10. It’s followed by the high-performance Mercedes-AMG S63 and BMW M8. The Porsche 911 Carrera Cabriolet and Bentley Continental GT also have spots in our top 10. Much more affordable is the Ford Mustang GT with a BuzzScore of 8.6, as well as the Audi A5 with an 8.5.

What are the cheapest four-seater cabrios in the USA?

If you are buying new, the tiny Mini Cooper is comparatively cheap and starts at under $30,000, but the convertible with the most rear legroom it is not. More practical, yet still well-priced, are the Chevrolet Camaro and Ford Mustang drop-tops, which begin at just over $30k.

BuzzScore
Design
Performance
MPG
Interior
Infotainment
Reliability
Safety
Value
#1
2020 Mercedes-Benz S-Class Convertible
9.5
BuzzScore
10
Design
9
Performance
9
MPG
10
Interior
10
Infotainment
8
Reliability
10
Safety
10
Value
#2
2020 Mercedes-AMG S63 Convertible
9.4
BuzzScore
10
Design
10
Performance
7
MPG
10
Interior
10
Infotainment
8
Reliability
10
Safety
10
Value
#3
2020 BMW M8 Convertible
9.3
BuzzScore
9
Design
10
Performance
8
MPG
9
Interior
10
Infotainment
9
Reliability
10
Safety
9
Value
#4
2020 Mercedes-AMG E53 Convertible
9.1
BuzzScore
9
Design
9
Performance
8
MPG
10
Interior
10
Infotainment
8
Reliability
10
Safety
9
Value
#5
2020 BMW 8 Series Convertible
9.1
BuzzScore
9
Design
9
Performance
8
MPG
9
Interior
10
Infotainment
9
Reliability
10
Safety
9
Value
#6
2021 Porsche 911 Turbo Cabriolet
9.1
BuzzScore
10
Design
10
Performance
8
MPG
9
Interior
10
Infotainment
9
Reliability
8
Safety
9
Value
#7
2020 Bentley Continental GT Convertible
9.1
BuzzScore
10
Design
10
Performance
8
MPG
10
Interior
9
Infotainment
8
Reliability
10
Safety
8
Value
#8
2021 Lexus LC Convertible
9
BuzzScore
10
Design
8
Performance
7
MPG
9
Interior
8
Infotainment
10
Reliability
10
Safety
10
Value
#9
2019 Mercedes-AMG S65 Convertible
9
BuzzScore
10
Design
9
Performance
7
MPG
10
Interior
10
Infotainment
8
Reliability
10
Safety
8
Value
#10
2020 Rolls-Royce Dawn
9
BuzzScore
10
Design
10
Performance
7
MPG
10
Interior
9
Infotainment
8
Reliability
10
Safety
8
Value
#11
2020 Mercedes-Benz E-Class Convertible
8.9
BuzzScore
9
Design
7
Performance
9
MPG
9
Interior
10
Infotainment
8
Reliability
10
Safety
9
Value
#12
2021 Porsche 911 Targa 4
8.8
BuzzScore
10
Design
9
Performance
8
MPG
8
Interior
8
Infotainment
10
Reliability
9
Safety
8
Value
#13
2018 BMW M6 Convertible
8.8
BuzzScore
9
Design
10
Performance
7
MPG
9
Interior
9
Infotainment
8
Reliability
10
Safety
8
Value
#14
2020 Ford Mustang GT Convertible
8.6
BuzzScore
9
Design
9
Performance
7
MPG
8
Interior
9
Infotainment
9
Reliability
10
Safety
8
Value
#15
2020 BMW 4 Series Convertible
8.6
BuzzScore
9
Design
8
Performance
9
MPG
9
Interior
9
Infotainment
9
Reliability
9
Safety
7
Value
#16
2020 Mercedes-AMG C43 Convertible
8.6
BuzzScore
8
Design
8
Performance
8
MPG
8
Interior
9
Infotainment
8
Reliability
10
Safety
10
Value
#17
2020 Chevrolet Camaro ZL1 Convertible
8.6
BuzzScore
9
Design
10
Performance
7
MPG
7
Interior
8
Infotainment
9
Reliability
10
Safety
9
Value
#18
2018 BMW 6 Series Convertible
8.6
BuzzScore
8
Design
8
Performance
8
MPG
9
Interior
9
Infotainment
9
Reliability
10
Safety
8
Value
#19
2021 Porsche 911 Carrera Cabriolet
8.6
BuzzScore
9
Design
9
Performance
8
MPG
8
Interior
8
Infotainment
10
Reliability
9
Safety
8
Value
#20
2020 Ford Mustang Convertible
8.5
BuzzScore
8
Design
7
Performance
8
MPG
8
Interior
9
Infotainment
9
Reliability
10
Safety
9
Value