Best Manual Sports Cars of 2024

Rowing your own gears isn’t for everyone, so it's understandable that manual sports cars cater mainly to enthusiasts who want full control from behind the wheel. Barring pricing and fuel economy benefits, sports cars with a stick shift are considered to be the ultimate in driving engagement; it’s little wonder that the most iconic and revered sports cars are the last few to boast a manual shifter.

Here is a list of the best sports cars with a manual transmission available in the USA for 2024:

BuzzScore
Design
Performance
MPG
Interior
Infotainment
Reliability
Safety
Value
#1
2023 Honda Civic Si Sedan
9.3
BuzzScore
9
Design
9
Performance
8
MPG
10
Interior
9
Infotainment
9
Reliability
10
Safety
10
Value
#2
2023 Volkswagen Golf GTI
9.3
BuzzScore
10
Design
9
Performance
7
MPG
10
Interior
10
Infotainment
8
Reliability
10
Safety
10
Value
#3
2023 Toyota GR86
9
BuzzScore
10
Design
8
Performance
8
MPG
10
Interior
9
Infotainment
9
Reliability
9
Safety
9
Value
#4
2023 Volkswagen Golf R
9
BuzzScore
9
Design
10
Performance
7
MPG
10
Interior
9
Infotainment
8
Reliability
9
Safety
10
Value
#5
2024 Honda Civic Type R
9
BuzzScore
9
Design
10
Performance
7
MPG
10
Interior
9
Infotainment
9
Reliability
9
Safety
9
Value
#6
2024 Acura Integra Type S
9
BuzzScore
9
Design
10
Performance
8
MPG
8
Interior
9
Infotainment
9
Reliability
10
Safety
9
Value
#7
2023 Volkswagen Jetta GLI
8.9
BuzzScore
8
Design
9
Performance
8
MPG
10
Interior
10
Infotainment
8
Reliability
9
Safety
9
Value
#9
2023 Porsche 911 Carrera
8.9
BuzzScore
9
Design
9
Performance
8
MPG
9
Interior
9
Infotainment
10
Reliability
9
Safety
8
Value
#10
2024 BMW M2
#10
BMW M2
8.8
BuzzScore
8
Design
9
Performance
8
MPG
9
Interior
9
Infotainment
9
Reliability
9
Safety
9
Value
#11
2023 Porsche 718 Boxster
8.8
BuzzScore
10
Design
10
Performance
8
MPG
8
Interior
8
Infotainment
9
Reliability
8
Safety
9
Value
#12
2023 Toyota GR Supra
8.6
BuzzScore
10
Design
10
Performance
8
MPG
8
Interior
8
Infotainment
9
Reliability
8
Safety
8
Value
#13
2023 Ford Mustang Mach 1
8.6
BuzzScore
10
Design
10
Performance
6
MPG
8
Interior
9
Infotainment
9
Reliability
8
Safety
9
Value
#14
2023 Porsche 718 Cayman
8.6
BuzzScore
9
Design
10
Performance
8
MPG
9
Interior
8
Infotainment
9
Reliability
8
Safety
8
Value
#15
2023 Chevrolet Camaro ZL1 Convertible
8.6
BuzzScore
9
Design
10
Performance
7
MPG
7
Interior
8
Infotainment
9
Reliability
10
Safety
9
Value
#16
2023 Cadillac CT5-V Blackwing
8.6
BuzzScore
9
Design
10
Performance
6
MPG
8
Interior
10
Infotainment
8
Reliability
8
Safety
10
Value
#17
2023 Porsche 718 Spyder
8.6
BuzzScore
10
Design
10
Performance
7
MPG
8
Interior
8
Infotainment
9
Reliability
8
Safety
9
Value
#18
2023 Porsche 911 GT3
8.6
BuzzScore
9
Design
10
Performance
8
MPG
9
Interior
8
Infotainment
9
Reliability
8
Safety
8
Value
#19
2023 Ford Mustang Convertible
8.5
BuzzScore
8
Design
7
Performance
8
MPG
8
Interior
9
Infotainment
9
Reliability
10
Safety
9
Value
#20
2023 Cadillac CT4-V Blackwing
8.5
BuzzScore
9
Design
10
Performance
8
MPG
7
Interior
10
Infotainment
8
Reliability
7
Safety
9
Value
#21
2023 BMW M4 Coupe
8.5
BuzzScore
8
Design
9
Performance
7
MPG
9
Interior
9
Infotainment
9
Reliability
9
Safety
8
Value

Characteristics of The Best Manual Sports Cars

Whether convertible, coupe, or sedan, the best manual sports cars have a few things in common:

  • They are revered for their exceptional driving experience
  • They generally offer excellent performance and thrilling handling
  • They can cost a lot of money because of their sports car designation
  • They require a bit more skill to manage

What to Consider When Buying Sports Cars With Manual Transmissions

If managing your own gear shifts is something you want to do, here is what you need to know about sports cars with manual transmissions:

Pros

  • Truly engaging for enthusiasts
  • Driver is in control of shifts and can tune driving style for performance or economy
  • Manual transmissions can return better fuel economy than auto ‘boxes
  • Lower curb weight in comparison to automatic-equipped vehicles
  • Generally cheaper than automatic versions of the same car

Cons

  • Not as quick to 60 mph as an automatic
  • Not everyone knows how to drive a stick shift

FAQs

What are some of the best manual sports cars?

The segment in the US is actually bigger than you’d think, with legendary models like the Mazda MX-5 Miata, Porsche 718 Cayman (and its Boxster sibling), and the BMW M2 taking up residence in it. BMW contributes to the segment with some 4-door manual sports cars like the BMW M3 sedan, while Honda offers the iconic Civic Type R. All of these are excellent in their own right.

Are cars with manual transmissions reliable?

Although some feel that automatic gearboxes are more complicated and require more maintenance, reliability really depends on how well you maintain your vehicle. In general, automakers with good warranty plans and low recall rates are your best bet.

Do sports cars with manual transmissions cost more than automatic-equipped versions?

Most of the time, automatic transmissions add to the total price, not the other way around, likely as a result of the more complicated technology. As an example, switching from the manual to the seven-speed automatic PDK transmission on the new Porsche 718 Cayman adds over $3,000 to the total bill.
Back
To Top