2021 Mazda MX-5 Miata RF

The current Miata is the lightest and most compact version so far. Add in a stiffer chassis, near-perfect weight distribution, and the wheelbase to width ratio that's supercar-like, and you have the perfect recipe for handling nirvana. Unfortunately, the RF adds 110 lbs to the worst possible place, raising the center of gravity. It is noticeable if you've driven the standard MX-5, but it's not a huge handicap if you want the benefit of a hardtop Miata.

Driving the Miata on the limit requires some know-how. Luckily, because the engine isn't that powerful, you can build up to it, learning the intricacies of Miata mobbing. If you jump on the brakes too early, the nose dips down, and the rear goes light. Get on the power too early, and it understeers. You need to find a rhythm with this car. It's not a get-in-and-go kind of performance car, as the margin for error is perhaps too slim. In the Miata, trust is earned.

The steering is sublimely weighted and provides loads of feedback. The standard brakes can take some punishment, but not a lot. They fade disappointingly quickly for a sports car like the Miata. Mazda offers a Brembo brake package to get around this, but we reckon it's just another reason to go for the manual. When the brakes start to fade, you can always rely on engine braking.

There's a reason the MX-5 has no real competitors in its class. It's an enthusiast's car at any level, whether it's a weekend driver, an everyday driver, or taken to the track for some more serious fun. You can spend much more on a roadster and even more on one with a retractable hard-top. You may get a faster car in a straight line, a swankier and more roomy interior, and something that impresses the neighbors, but the MX-5 delivers a pure driving experience with reliability and cost-efficiency that can't be matched. Now the MX-5 is well into its lifecycle, small issues have been ironed out, and the addition of Apple CarPlay and Android Auto completes the car for us.

But what of the RF? Well, unless you live in an area that needs the extra insulation, the RF is tough to sell. It looks damn good, but there's less practicality here, and the weight is in the wrong place. For us, the MX-5 Miata is about purity, and the RF isn't the purest distillation of the MX-5 ethos there is. Still, even an RF is better than no MX-5 at all.

The RF MX-5 was introduced to offer a more refined daily experience. The hardtop roof provides better insulation against noise, and it has minimal impact on the dynamics. Better yet, you don't have to manually raise and lower it. Still, if refinement is high on your list, virtually any coupe out there will do a better job. The MX-5 has always been about the roof-down roadster experience, and in our opinion, the soft-top still does a better job, not least of all because the soft-top lowers the weight and improves the practicality.

A base Miata with a soft top, which you want, starts at $26,830. You only get the basics in terms of comfort and infotainment, but if you're in the market for an MX-5, it's the driving experience that matters. The entry-level soft top represents a massive $6,215 saving over the base price of the RF, but the latter comes in a higher standard spec. On a like-for-like basis, the RF is still nearly $3,000 more. We can't quite justify this, so we'd rather opt for the soft-top and enjoy the Miata the way it was meant to be enjoyed. But we wouldn't fault you for picking the RF.

While, historically, the Miata RF would've been a great comparison with the Toyota 86 due to its hardtop nature, in 2021, there isn't an 86. That's because the all-new 2022 GR 86 has just been unveiled, and things don't look good for the Mazda. That's because the 2022 GR 86 has a larger, 2.4-liter boxer engine, now generating 228 hp and 184 lb-ft of torque, with a better torque curve, too, which should make it counter its heftier weight to provide ample performance to rival the Miata RF. But it's vastly more practical, retaining a 2+2 seating arrangement and boasting a relatively spacious trunk. Compared to that, the Miata RF is completely impractical. However, for most Miata buyers, the ability to go topless is what will always matter, and the fact that the 86 is a fixed-roof coupe means that it'll never even cross their minds.

We'll have to wait and see how the new 86 drives, but the competition may now be closer than ever between these two rivals. And the fact that there may not be a new Miata for a few years means Mazda could be in for a tough time.