Turbochargers Vs. Superchargers: Which Is Better And How The Hell Do They Work?


You're about to learn today.

Decisionsare hard to make, especially when you’re talking about what modification to puton your car. Should you use adjustable springs? How about progressive rate?Cross drilled or slotted brake rotors? How about what to decide when it comesto forced induction? This can be tricky, and there’s no real right or wronganswer. The skinny is, they both force more airflow into the engine but invery different ways. Simply put, the supercharger runs off of the crankshaftand the turbo runs off of exhaust gasses.

Let’s look at them more in depth though. With a supercharger, a belt is wrapped around a pulley and connected to the crankshaft. With this in mind the supercharger is spinning at the same speed as the crankshaft at all times. There's all this spinning, but what does it do?

You Might Also Like
Family Cars With The Biggest Trunks
Family Cars With The Biggest Trunks
10 Rarest Porsches Ever Made
10 Rarest Porsches Ever Made

If we’re talking about a twin screw supercharger then it's two grooved rods that fit together spinning next to each other, acting like fans pulling air into the engine at a rapid rate. The good thing about a supercharger is that extra power is immediate. As soon as you hit the gas, the supercharger is throwing more air into the engine and your forced induction is showing results right away. The problem with this setup is that it’s run off of the crankshaft. Power will be provided immediately, that’s true, but at some point the fact that it's run off of the crankshaft means it’ll eventually start taking power away from the engine. It has a peak effectiveness, which doesn’t take very long to get to, and then it becomes just another accessory like an alternator.

Sure it’s providing power, but because it’s only going to be around 7 psi it’s not the greatest amount of boost, and it will not last for too long. On the flip side, a turbocharger, which is run off of exhaust gas, takes much longer to build up power but it only does so if you want it to.

If enough exhaust goes through the compressor at a high enough pressure, the turbo will start to store it and run it back through the intake, thus recycling the unused fuel. Otherwise it would normally get dumped through the rest of the exhaust system. This spells efficiency. As for it being slower than a supercharger, there are ways around that but are significantly more expensive, such as a twin scroll turbocharger or a twin turbo setup. What manufacturers will do sometimes is tune the computer to keep one turbo spooled while the other builds pressure, each turbo handling one half of the cylinders. This is what BMW did with the E92 335i that used the N54 twin turbo charged engine. Now let’s talk about application.

Since superchargers are so quick to delegate boost, the kind of racing that can really benefit from it is drag racing. You need immediate power and lots of it at low-end RPMs, and that’s what a supercharger is good for. Turbocharging, however, is better for road courses. Lots of racetracks have one or two big straights, so there’s plenty of room to build boost and spend it. Also because the boost isn’t always there the problem of wheel spin isn’t always there either. The down side is that turbocharging is way more complicated and expensive. So really, what are you going to use your forced induction for? Both have benefits and idiosyncrasies, but they both have their place with cars.

It's important then to do a ton of research on the engine that you are planning to put forced induction on. Either way, have a good time and prepare for potentially bad gas mileage, trees that appear as if from outta nowhere, and annihilating damn near anything on the road in a race.

Jaguar XE 300 Sport And XE SV Project 8 Create Modern Art

Two vastly different sports sedans that share a common thread.

All-New Revolutionary Mazda3 Teased Ahead Of LA Reveal

Along with its game-changing sparkless ignition engine.

WatchThe Extraordinary Nissan GT-R50 Being Built By Hand

It’s all about bending sheet metal the old-fashioned way.

Here's How Aerodynamics Make The Lamborghini Aventador SVJ So Much Faster

Take a behind the scenes look at this amazing system.

Fake Lamborghini Murcielago SV Reverse-Engineered By Iran

The Chinese couldn’t have done it better.

Hennessey Trackhawk Is World's Quickest SUV

That's what a thousand horsepower will do for ya.

5 Things You Need To Know About The 2019 BMW X5

After driving the car for the first time, here are our key takeaways.

Watch The BMW M2 Competition Lap The Ring In 7:52

That was supercar territory not long ago.

Kim Jong-un Gets Classy With New Ride

So much for sanctions.

What's Hot

Related Cars

Starting MSRP
Starting MSRP
Starting MSRP

Related Reviews

2016 Cadillac CTS-V Review: 5 Reasons You Should Buy This  Over The BMW M5
Test Drive
2016 Cadillac CTS-V Review: 5 Reasons You Should Buy This Over The BMW M5
2017 BMW 3 Series Sedan Review
BMW 3 Series Sedan
2017 BMW 3 Series Sedan Review
2018 BMW M3 Review
Model Overview
2018 BMW M3 Review
2017 Cadillac CTS-V Sedan  Review
Model Overview
2017 Cadillac CTS-V Sedan Review